Breast is best, I agree. But for the first time I have a formula drinking bottle chugger…and I love it.
I breast fed all three of my children, and I had absolutely zero problems doing so. Zip. All three kids latched on like pros in the delivery rooms. No pain, great supply. My husband was completely supportive. I perfected both the “modest beneath a pink-patterned cover” and “nonchalant People’s Park boob flasher” nursing styles.
Charlie and Eve never experienced bottles. I was home with them and so was able to serve as their sole provider of milk. Breastfed exclusively for thirteen and fifteen months respectively, nary a drop of formula nor silicone nipple touched their lips.
Of course, nary a night went by that they were not up multiple times to chug my personally-made moo juice. It was exhausting.
Sure, I could have introduced bottles. But I had such an easy, blissful time nursing the babies the first three months that I missed the primo window for introducing a bottle after breastfeeding is firmly established (my pediatrician says around 4 weeks old for a full-term baby). I could have pumped so that Chris could lend a hand. But I hated the electric dairy contraption, had a tough time finding the time, never needed to leave them and oh yeah, I didn’t introduce bottles to the kids at all so there goes the milk delivery device.
For a few years there I eagerly awaited the Perfect Mom Award I believed I was going to be awarded for never giving Charlie or Eve a bottle or formula. Then I realized…no one gives a flying fart how I fed my babies.
The decision to introduce a bottle and formula to Alice was made completely on the fly. At five weeks old, around 5 p.m. one night, Alice was intermittently nursing and crying inconsolably. Was this colic? Neither of the first two kids had had that either (I know, I know, we have had it disgustingly easy). Full of that edgy anxiety that can come on during the postpartum period, I handed Alice to Chris. He could not soothe her either, and she became more agitated.
So I headed to the obscure kitchen cabinet where I had stashed, just in case, the Similac Advance gift pack from the hospital. Inside was a newborn flow bottle and a can of powdered formula. I followed the directions for sterilizing the bottle, added the formula and tepid filtered water, and handed to Chris.
Alice chugged down four ounces, heartily burped, and then slept for six hours solid.
I kept on nursing Alice throughout the day and sometimes night, but we instituted a big bottle of formula right before bed. We kept this one bottle a day until around six months of age, when Alice began waking throughout the night and using my breasts as her favorite teething ring. We introduced more bottles. As a mom constantly on the go carting the older kids to activities and to and from school, I preferred bottles’ convenience. Alice seemed equally happy snuggling with either my boob or a bottle of the powdered stuff.
In The Girlfriends’ Guide to Surviving the First Year of Motherhood, Vicki Iovine calls bottles and formula “…a giant slippery slope that could only end in the baby and I becoming formula junkies.” I finally understood what she meant.
Also, I do not get my period when I am nursing at all. Just one nip a day from baby and Aunt Flo is off on a cruise. This sounds cool at first. No mess! Parrrty! But in actuality, it means my hormones are stalled in PMS for months. Seriously.
Once my kids get a taste of rice cereal and Cuisinarted squash at six months of age, I no longer have those post-baby “reunited and it feels so good” happy endorphins flowing through my body. I also don’t have the nice and normal ebb and flow of regular hormones that ovulation and menstruation provide.
I am stuck, stuck I say!, in a horrible PMS that feels like I am on Annuale.
I have a husband and three kids. They don’t deserve to live with a nutjob while I am praying for my period like Margaret Simon, Nancy Wheeler, Gretchen Potter and Janie Loomis combined.
So, that’s the story of how my third baby was off the boob completely by eight months. She received five-seven months less than her siblings of that magical top reading group-achieving human lactose. But on formula and solid food meals, she takes two daily naps and sleeps 10-11 hours a night without interruption. No “cry it out”, no ear infections, no reptilian scales.
I had no problems nursing, plenty of support, plenty of milk, and still I chose to wean before one year of age.
And oh yeah, I got my period, returned to my normal neurotic but not psychotic self, and lost the last 10 pounds.
Alice loves her formula, and so do I.













Comments
Stacy
You and I are the exact same, I’ve nursed both kids until age two. If I ever have a third, there will be so much formula it isn’t even silly. Thanks for being so frank and honest, I will totally try to not feel bad about it.
[Reply]
admin Reply:
March 27th, 2012 at 4:57 pm
Thanks Stacy! I never would have imagined that I would be a Similac poster girl before her first b-day. But as she is turning one at the end of April, only one more month to feel guilty about the formula, and just one year left to feel funny about the not nursing, ha ha.
[Reply]
Amber Mc.
I say to mothers every single day, “What works for mom and baby is what works.” I work hard against the barriers to breastfeeding that mothers encounter so that they can be empowered to find what is the right fit for their families. Many make the assumption that because I am a lactation consultant, I am a “lactivist”…nope, I’m a “mom-tivist”z
[Reply]
admin Reply:
March 27th, 2012 at 4:58 pm
Thank you SO MUCH Amber!! You know, I thought about interviewing you for this piece but then I didn’t have act together to coordinate that. Can I for a future post?? xoxo
[Reply]
Amber Mc. Reply:
March 28th, 2012 at 1:37 pm
Absolutely! I’d love that. These are issues that I talk about every single day and I feel very passionate about. As with all decisions, there are consequences (good and bad). When we have knowledge, we can feel confident in choosing what is right for us. You didn’t go into this blind. I take my births, for example. I chose to have an epidural all 3 times. Some of those around me would say that I was forced, coerced, lied to. Nope, I did a lot of research, knew what the consequences could be, and made my choice. Were there effects on our breastfeeding relationship because of that? You bet. But, because I was knowledgable, was I able to overcome those. Yes. I count feeding choices as the same.
[Reply]
Micaela W
I went back to work when my oldest was an infant, and he received most,y formula. I was home with my youngest and nursed him to 13 months without using formula. Despite this, my youngest always had a million colds, ear infections, and was a horrible sleeper. If I have a third child, I am definitely going to “mix it up” like you. People get so opinionated about some baby rearing topics that it drives me crazy! Thanks for this great post, Happy momma=happy kids!
[Reply]
admin Reply:
March 27th, 2012 at 5:01 pm
Thank you for making the excellent point that while breast feeding does increase immunities and promote excellent health in infants, when you compare individual kids on a case-by-case basis a breastfed baby is not automatically superior healthwise or any other way when compared to a baby receiving formula.
Great point and thanks for sharing!
[Reply]
Elaine
I had so much trouble nursing with my first, and it was really hard for me not to consider myself a failure for that bottle of formula he had every day. He’s six and I still feel let down about it. My second was easy-peasy. I had over-supply with her and was able to exclusively breastfeed for 10 months (she had major reflux, so introducing food just didn’t happen) and then I nursed her and she had food as well until she was 2.5, when we finally weaned. It’s among the sweetest memories I have. That said, the best piece of parenting advice I ever received was from a dear friend, when I was struggling so much with my first. “Elaine, formula is a blessing. It is the reason infants in this country rarely die from lack of nutrition.” Glad you’ve found what works for you and your whole family. What works can really run the spectrum!
[Reply]
admin Reply:
March 27th, 2012 at 5:03 pm
I am so so so glad you had such a fabulous experience nursing Helen and found what worked for you with her.
I have had lots of friends also say that while nursing their first baby was tough, nursing subsequent babies was much easier. I wonder, does a previously-used lactation system work better?
[Reply]
MusingsfromMe/Jill
That Annuale clip is hilarious. I’m not a regular SNL watcher, so miss the really good sketches.
I tried to breastfeed my first child. We lasted three weeks. She was steadily losing weight. The doctor was concerned! I had a myriad of issues: slow recovery from c-section, inverted nipples, ineffective pumping, and a baby who could not latch on whatever I tried to do. I was an emotional wreck. I spilled about 1 ounce of pumped breast milk and bawled…I’m not a crier at all. I knew that by 4 weeks I would need to pickup my freelance work, which would mean that the baby would need to be on some sort of napping schedule, so I switched over a period of days to formula. Like you, I had a case of free Similiac. She guzzled that bottle of formula as though she were dying of hunger. Once on formula she slept like a champ for about 5-6 hours at night and two 3-hour naps a day. It was a true miracle as I needed to get work done during the day as my husband was in grad school and couldn’t help me in the evenings.
Thank you for posting your experience. I’m sure it will be helpful for anyone struggling.
[Reply]
admin Reply:
March 27th, 2012 at 5:06 pm
Thanks for sharing your experience Jill. Like you, it was the longer stretches of sleep when baby was “tanked up” on formula that brought me to the other side.
Also glad, as a Tina Fey groupie (awesome coincidence - her daughter is also named Alice!), that you were able to view one of her all-time funniest writings, the Annuale ad. It is genius.
[Reply]
Stimey
Jack moved to formula at six months because I stopped making milk, and I gotta say, it made life pretty easy. I mean, sure, you have to make sure that you have formula with you all the time, but I do have to say, there was a lot of freedom to it.
[Reply]
admin Reply:
March 30th, 2012 at 8:57 am
Thanks for the vote of support! Alice sends a baby fist bump to Jack.
[Reply]
Nicole
I have always said, whatever works for you and your family is the best thing. People are often scared into believing that you cannot nurse and offer bottles of formula. I hate the whole nipple confusion argument. It is baloney. I nursed and offered formula to all four of my kids (I HATE pumping). I nursed when I was with them and gave formula when it was more convenient, or I needed a break. I had no problems with this plan. The body adjusts and so do our babies. I nursed for 13 months, 6 months, 9 months, and am now on 11 months with my last. Thanks for sharing your story!
[Reply]
Jessica Reply:
April 2nd, 2012 at 11:29 am
Thanks Nicole. Your feedback is so helpful (and calming). Also, congrats on your new site! I’m adding you to both my blogrolls. 🙂
[Reply]
TRicia S
Great story. I was a mom who desperately wanted to nurse but my milk never came in. My first was a premie and the Dr.s said that was why but my second was full term minus a week and still no milk. I was really sad at first and felt inadequate and thought I would never have that bonding with my babies. Turned out that formula was great, they are both happy healthy kids and looking back it was great being able to share it with my husband. We are a happy and very close family. We always feel like we could have done more but we do what we can and know that they are loved and fed and they aren’t going to be affected by it. You and Alice are getting more sleep so I’m sure you are enjoying your time together even more!
[Reply]
admin Reply:
April 5th, 2012 at 5:22 pm
As someone who knows your kids personally, I can say that you all are seriously, wonderfully bonded. And yes, getting better sleep at night is great for both me and Alice and the rest of the family. (But especially me.)
[Reply]
Reginald
Hi
[Reply]
Sac Longchamp Pliage Sacs Longchamps Pas Cher 75
tote bags with logo are definitely one the best promotional products. They are fitting for any marketing campaign and offer limitless avenues to increase your brand awareness amongst the national. They are a require to be paid or undergone sufficient way to reward your employees and clients while at the same time creating durable continuance|lasting} method of brand and yield promotion. In method to ensure you reap greatest benefits, you should consider several aspects of the barter show totes and your troop.
[Reply]
HardX
You’ll find all the hot girls and all the sexy bikinis in one showcase.
We simply love HardX. News Now reported actress model
and sometimes-troubled movie star Lindsay Lohan spend Monday on the sand wearing nothing but an electric
blue bikini. Hard X now, However, if you have a models
body, slipping into boy short swimwear will add sex appeal by the truckload.
[Reply]